High Society Cheesecake delivered right to your door! Orders ship Tuesdays

Featured products

“Spiced Caramel Apple (Eye of Eden) (Ships Tuesdays)” has been added to your cart. View cart

Showing all 12 results

Black Velvet (Project Vessel) (Ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
Project Vessel – Sleep Token Inspired Cheesecake

Project Vessel isn’t just dessert—it’s an experience. Inspired by the darker side of sound and stage, this cheesecake embodies intensity with layers of depth and complexity.

It begins with all-natural black cocoa, giving the base its strikingly dark, bittersweet profile. But just as the richness settles in, pure vanilla softens the edges, transforming the bitterness into a smooth, indulgent chocolate foundation.

Then comes the twist! Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream. Its notes of oak and spice rise through the cocoa, leaving a warm, lingering finish that elevates every bite. To complete the composition, we layer in strawberries and cake crumble, adding both visual drama and the classic harmony of chocolate and strawberries.

Driven by the atmosphere of songs like “Look to Windward,” “Emergence,” “Even in Arcadia,” and “The Summoning,” this cheesecake is bold, brooding, and unforgettable.

Flavor profile: Dark cocoa · Vanilla · Bourbon Cream · Strawberries · Cake Crumble

Add to cart
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
Cookie dough pieces bombing Bailey’s infused cheesecake studded with chocolate chips throughout.

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Everyone’s Favorite Sampler (Ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
A true crowd pleaser: Triple Chocolate, Cherry, Cookies N’ Cream, & Original Cheesecake. Three slices of each flavor, 12 slices total.

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Gift Kit #1 (Ships Tuesdays)
$35.99
Perfect for gifting to someone else or getting that end of the week pick up you need!

Includes: One 12oz pint of Scoopable Cheesecake (your choice), a Chocolate Chunk Cheesecake Cookie Sandwich, and a one of our 4″ Signature Caramel Brownies!

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Mini Cheesecakes, Variety 16 pack (Ships Tuesdays)
$74.99
Try a little of everything with our 16 pack of Mini Cheesecakes set. 8 flavors in each box!

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Original (Ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
The Classic. Smooth, creamy vanilla hinted cheesecake. Enough said.

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Scoopable Cheesecake (All 9 Scoops) (Ships Tuesdays)
$84.99
You’ve seen the scoop. Now it’s your turn.

We handcraft every flavor in small batches using real ingredients, no shortcuts. Then we freeze it at peak indulgence and ship it with insulated packaging and dry ice, straight to your doorstep. (GF) = Gluten Free

Each bite is a moment: silky, tangy, rich, and totally scoopable.

✓ Get all nine flavors
✓ Ships anywhere in the U.S.
✓ Perfect for gifts, parties, or personal celebration

It’s not ice cream. It’s better.

Add to cart
Scoopable Cheesecake Mixer (choose 3 flavors) (Ships Tuesdays)
$84.99
You choose three flavors and get three of each! or choose all the same and get nine of your favorite flavor this month!

You’ve seen the scoop. Now it’s your turn.

We handcraft every flavor in small batches using real ingredients, no shortcuts. Then we freeze it at peak indulgence and ship it with insulated packaging and dry ice, straight to your doorstep. (GF) = Gluten Free

Each bite is a moment: silky, tangy, rich, and totally scoopable.

✓ Pick your flavors
✓ Ships anywhere in the U.S.
✓ Perfect for gifts, parties, or personal celebration

It’s not ice cream. It’s better.

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Spiced Caramel Apple (Eye of Eden) (Ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
Eye of Eden – Sleep Token Inspired Cheesecake

Behold, the Eye of Eden—a cheesecake inspired by fans across the galaxy and guided by songs like “Caramel,” “Alkaline,” “Granite,” and “Take Me Back to Eden.” This flavor is a tribute to the paradise once lost, a garden of sweetness that lingers only in memory.

At its heart is the apple, symbolizing both temptation and complexity—the forbidden fruit that is as alluring as it is unattainable. To elevate this foundation, we layer in caramel and honey, creating a decadent sweetness that’s nearly impossible to resist.

But Eden, as we know it, is beyond reach. To capture the dream of returning, we infuse the cheesecake with a blend of cinnamon, cardamom, clove, and nutmeg—warm spices long associated with rest and dreaming. Finally, it’s crowned with our house-made vanilla bean whip, caramel swirl, and a crumble of Biscoff cookies, sealing the flavor in an unforgettable finish.

Flavor profile: Apple · Caramel · Honey · Warm Spices · Vanilla Bean Whip · Biscoff Crumble

Add to cart
Turtle (Ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
We took our classic original cheesecake & spun ribbons of caramel & fudge thoughout. Then finished this masterpiece with a thick layer of fudge, a double caramel lattice, & crushed pecans.

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Two 12oz Scoopable Cheesecake Pack
$35.99
Perfect for gifting to someone you love or getting that end of the week pick up you need! Send it to your friends for their birthday, your college student for a mid week pick up, or a grandson just to tell him how special he is!

Includes: Two 12oz pints of Scoopable Cheesecake straight from our bar!

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
White Chocolate Raspberry (Ships Tuesdays)
$43.99
White chocolate cheesecake with the addition of raspberry liquer to insure raspberry flavor in every bite plus swirls of raspberry puree & white chocolate ribbons.

Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page